Summary
- In Maxima LT (Case C-497/25), Latvia taxed income from the disposal of shares in 13 Latvian companies, while the Netherlands ultimately exempted that income.
- Advocate General Laulhé Shaelou considers that “double taxation” under Directive (EU) 2017/1852 requires actual taxation by at least two Member States, not merely overlapping taxing rights.
- If followed by the Court of Justice of the European Union, the opinion could allow Member States to refuse access to an Advisory Commission where a treaty dispute remains unresolved but only one country has imposed tax.
Extended article
Advocate General Laulhé Shaelou has proposed a restrictive interpretation of “double taxation” under the EU Tax Dispute Resolution Mechanisms Directive in UAB Maxima LT v Valsts ieņēmumu dienests (Case C-497/25).
The case concerns income received by Lincoln Land Erste B.V., a Netherlands company whose legal successor is UAB Maxima LT, from the disposal of shares in 13 Latvian companies. Latvia taxed the transaction, whereas the income was ultimately exempt in the Netherlands. The dispute therefore involved competing interpretations of the Latvia-Netherlands tax treaty, but no tax was effectively levied in the Netherlands.
After the competent authorities failed to resolve the disagreement through the mutual agreement procedure, UAB Maxima LT requested the establishment of an Advisory Commission. Latvia refused, relying on article 16(7) of Directive (EU) 2017/1852, which permits access to this stage to be denied where the matter does not involve double taxation. The Latvian court subsequently referred three questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union. [eur-lex.europa.eu], [juris.curi….europa.eu]
The Advocate General concluded that article 2(1)(c) requires actual taxation in at least two Member States. The provision refers to the “imposition” of tax and requires an additional tax charge, increased liability, or a reduction of available losses. Merely exposing income to two national tax systems is insufficient where one Member State grants an exemption.
The opinion distinguishes between access to the mutual agreement procedure and access to an Advisory Commission. Treaty-interpretation disputes may enter the mutual agreement procedure even without actual double taxation. However, Member States may reserve the subsequent Advisory Commission stage for cases involving an effective economic tax burden in more than one jurisdiction.
For taxpayers, the opinion highlights a potential protection gap. A significant treaty disagreement may remain unresolved even though the taxpayer cannot compel arbitration because relief granted in one country removes actual double taxation. The final judgment should therefore be monitored closely, particularly for disputes involving exemptions, participation regimes or territorial tax systems. The case is also the first preliminary ruling request concerning the Directive. [shop.ibfd.org]
Further reading: Official case record for Case C-497/25 | Directive (EU) 2017/1852


